Can You Help Someone By Just Asking Them Questions?

Guest Post by Hal Mayer

Over the years I have discovered when people bring me their problems and ask for help, if I am able to use the principles and framework in my new book “Smart Ask? Questions That Lead Your Team to Win”  – it is a win/win. 

This “Post” was originally posted on this Blog –  in March of 2016.  Bob told me it drew a lot of interest. I decided to expand on the original article and write a book.  Here is an actual coaching session where I used this framework (detailed in “Smart Ask?”) to guide the discussion:

Hal:  Who has a real problem or situation they are struggling with and would like some coaching?  I will not embarrass you.  Tanisha raised her hand and I invited her to the front.

Hal: Tanisha, what is the problem you would like some help with?

Tanisha: I am the children’s minister here and I need more volunteers.

Hal: Ok. Let’s talk about that. Let’s set a goal for the meeting. Can we do that?

Tanisha: Yes, if you could help me get 10 new volunteers; that would make a productive day for me.

Hal: Let’s clarify our goal a little bit. What can we do in this meeting that will help achieve your goal? We are not going to call people and list them here. So, what could we do?

Tanisha:  Okay.  If I could leave with a couple good ideas on how I could enlist new people that would make for a productive meeting.

Hal: Perfect! Let’s go. Tell me what is happening now in children’s ministry and what you have tried?

Tanisha: The church is growing fast, we have been adding services and are behind on enlisting children’s leaders, we lost some people too moving away. All this happened at a really crucial time and I needed to build the children’s pipeline back up. I tried pulpit announcements and e-mails and it hadn’t worked and I need something new to do.

Hal: Let me ask you this question. If you could try and do anything,  and money was not an object what would you do to find new volunteers? Would you mind if I write these down – I will give the sheet to you at the end?

Tanisha: OK. Anyone who volunteered to serve I would buy them movie tickets.

Hal: Alright let’s build a list, What else?

Tanisha: I would give them $100.00 to serve.

Hal: OK. What else?

Tanisha: We could give an announcement from the pulpit.

Hal: Anything else?

Tanisha: We could send an email with a link they could click, which would reply back to my leaders and me.

Hal: OK, Anything else?

Tanisha: We could have lemonade stand in the lobby during all the services and staff it with kids and workers and have applications available?

Hal: OK, Anything else?

Tanisha: I could “hall” tackle 3 people a week and ask them if they would serve?

Hal: Alright, anything else?  At that point she was out of ideas.  I said, OK, let’s talk about these.  I read and showed the list to her; you mentioned offering movie tickets, paying people $100.00 to serve, a pulpit announcement, sending an email, a lemonade stand, and you mentioned hall tackling people. Which one of those interests you and you would like to talk further about?

Tanisha: I would really like to talk about the lemonade stand.

Hal: Ok, tell me about your ideas for the lemonade stand? (I continue to take notes)

Tanisha: We would give free lemonade and staff it with kids and workers. We would have a video running in the background about our ministry and applications available to complete.  We would focus on talking to people who would stop and look.

Hal: If you did this, when would you do it?

Tanisha: This is Tuesday; I would do it this Sunday.

Hal: Wow, that is a quick turn around. What would you need to get ready?

Tanisha: I would need a TV from AV and get it set up. I would need to enlist people to be there and would need the lemonade.

Hal: Is there anything else?

Tanisha: No, I think that is everything.

Hal: Is there anything that could derail this plan? Something unforeseen and she thought for a moment.

Tanisha: Well, I better involve leadership and make sure they are on board with this plan. I don’t want to move forward if there is a problem and we need to cancel.

Hal: That is a good plan. Anything else?

Tanisha: No.

Hal: Alright, here is the deal. (I show her my notes again) You said, you will set up a lemonade stand and staff it with kids and workers, and have a video in the background showing how exciting it is to work in the children’s ministry. Have applications available to get people started with volunteering. Right?

Tanisha: Yes.

Hal: And, you are going to do it this Sunday?

Tanisha: Yes.

Hal: And, you have the things you need?

Tanisha: Yes.

Hal: OK, when you do it, I am not going to be here, but would you take a picture and tag me on Instagram.

Tanisha: Yes!

Hal:  (Show her the notes again) Did we reach our goal? Our goal was to get an idea or a few ideas?

Tanisha: Yes, we did.

Hal: (Debrief for those wondering why I did each level)

The meeting took about 20 minutes. I began with the question, “ Tell me what is going on?”  Let them say what their needs are. This will allow them to draw focus on their challenge. Then ask, Let’s set a goal.  What is important with the goal is to set one, which can be completed in that meeting. Then talk with them about what they have tried and the things that are happening within the ministry.  Then ask them, “If money wasn’t an object what would they try?” The reason for these questions is to listen, build a list and not evaluate by saying no. I don’t want to qualify their ideas.  I only write them down. I always ask permission to take notes, because I give them a copy of the notes.

This helps to get the flow going as long as I am not evaluating their ideas. People may begin with ideas they often know will not work. But, it is ok to let them get it out of the way.   They will continue moving down the list and I will ask many times, “is there anything else?” I may ask them this 10 times. It may feel like I am asking the question a lot but it doesn’t feel that way to them. Then I would read the list back to them and ask, “Any one of these interests you?”

Then they will talk about the one they are interested in. The key to understanding is people are going to do the best work on what they are interested in, not necessarily what you think is the best idea. As long as it makes sense and it fits within our vision, that is OK. Their buy-in is the key.

Then I help them set some objectives. I ask, “ What would it take to get this idea ready”?  They would make the list. Then I would ask, “What could happen that might block this?” They may not have thought of something. They may mention a few thoughts and you would talk through those challenges and solutions. Afterwards, you say, OK, great! Let me know how it goes.

I used questions the whole way through, not to tell Tanisha what to do; she was the expert but to help her work through the maze. What happens often for leaders is we get this haze going and this mist where it is hard to see what is going on. With questions we can help them draw focus.  You will notice that I did not qualify anything she said, I did not pick the item she wanted to work on.  All I did was ask questions to help her draw focus. It is often the case a few weeks after the meeting.  They will try to contact me, but I am unavailable and they begin to ask themselves the same questions. What they realize is that they do not have to ask Hal the questions. They can ask themselves the questions. Then they begin what is called self-coaching. Just a few ideas I have used to coach individuals and I hope you find these helpful.

In “Smart Ask? Questions That Lead Your Team to Win”  I share an equation for deepening buy-in from those we lead.   I often hear about the need for engagement or buy-in in the workplace.  Here is the equation PVI x BI = ROI.   You will find the full explanation in  “Smart Ask?”.

Note From Bob:  Out of over 1,000 posts to date, Hal’s post on March 28, 2016 continues to be the 5th Most Popular!  It gives me great pleasure to know that my friend Hal has now turned his “Guest Post” into a wonderful new book!   You can purchase your  “Smart Ask?”  book today in a Kindle or paperback format by clicking HERE to find it on Amazon.

Hal Mayer


Hal Mayer currently coaches pastors and business leaders.  He has invested many years training and developing training leaders to succeed in ministry and the workplace.  You can check Hal out on his website,, . You can also find him on Twitter, Instagram and Linked-In.  Hal and his wife Sandy have two married adult children and 4 GrandKids which they adore.



Reporting Questions

Guest Post by Bobb Biehl Once your priorities (measurable problems, goals, opportunities) are clear, these...

13 CEOs Share Their Favorite Job Interview Questions

Interview questions: Everyone has them. And everyone wishes they had better...

15 Astute Questions To Ask Other Leaders

Guest Post By Indeed Editorial Team Previously posted at  Questions to Ask Leaders for Career...

Is It True?

Today - one day before Good Friday and 3 days before Easter - may I share with you the story of "3 Questions"...

Key Insights From “Good Leaders Ask Great Questions”

Guest Post by Artem Gurnov Growing as a leader means constantly challenging yourself to help raise your team...

Questions for Your Next Daddy-Daughter Date

Men, if you have been blessed with a daughter then you know that there is something really special about the...


Excerpted with permission from the 3rd Chapter of “Uncommon Greatness: Five Fundamentals to Transform...

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.